Astronomy Now Home
Home Magazine Resources Store

On Sale Now!



The October 2014 issue of Astronomy Now is on sale! Order direct from our store (free 1st class post & to UK addresses). Astronomy Now is the only astronomy magazine specially designed to be read on tablets and phones. Download the app from Google Play Store or the Apple App Store.



Top Stories



Earthshine used to test life detection method
...By imagining the Earth as an exoplanet, scientists observing our planet's reflected light on the Moon with ESO's Very Large Telescope have demonstrated a way to detect life on other worlds...
  READ MORE

Solid buckyballs discovered in space
...Astronomers using NASA’s Spitzer Space Telescope have detected a particular type of molecule, given the nickname “buckyball”, in a solid form for the first time...
  READ MORE

Steamy water-world gets the Hubble treatment
...Hubble Space Telescope observations of a 7 Earth-mass planet find an unusual water-rich world swathed in a thick, steamy atmosphere...
  READ MORE








Fourth gas giant poses problems for formation
DR EMILY BALDWIN
ASTRONOMY NOW
Posted: 10 December 2010


Bookmark and Share

A fourth giant planet uncovered in the HR 8799 system poses problems for models of planet formation – neither established theory can explain the in situ formation of all four planets.

Two years ago, three planets were directly imaged at infrared wavelengths using the Keck and Gemini telescopes in Hawaii orbiting the star HR 8799, a 1.5 solar mass main sequence star located 129 light years away in the constellation of Pegasus. The system also possesses a dusty disc much like our own Kuiper Belt, with the giant planets orbiting within the disc's inner edge.


An image of HR 8799e obtained at the Keck II telescope, refined using NRC’s adaptive optics system, showing all four confirmed planets. Arrows illustrate possible planet orbital motions for the next ten years. Image: NRC-HIA, C. Marois & Keck Observatory.

Now, additional analysis reveal a fourth planet orbiting just 14.5 AU (astronomical unit, equivalent to the Earth-Sun separation) from the central star, with a mass around ten Jupiter masses. Its companion planets orbit at distances of 24, 38 and 68 AU and are 10, 10 and 7 Jupiter-masses respectively.

The system is currently the only known example of a wide (greater than 25 AU) system with multiple giant planets, but this presents a problem for theories of planet formation, which occurs by one of two processes. In the core accretion "bottom-up" model, a rocky core builds up through collisions of smaller rocky bodies, until its gravity is great enough to trap a gassy atmosphere. In the gravitational collapse "top-down" model, instabilities in the star's primordial disc leads to fragmentation, i.e. clumps of matter condense out and attract further gas and eventually dusty debris that sinks to the core.

In the case of HR 8799, the core accretion model would allow the innermost planet, HR 8799e, to form within 10 million years before the star's gas disc had dissipated, but HR 8799c would need 20 times longer to grow to its mass at 38 AU, by which point the disc would have lost its mass, and at 68 AU core accretion would exceed the age of the star, an impossible situation. On the other hand, the gravitational instability model cannot explain the formation of the innermost planet, because the star's primordial disc would not have been cold enough or rotating slowly enough to fragment and collapse to form the planet in situ.

"It is not obvious that you can form planets by both scenarios in the same system," lead author of the study Christian Marois of Canada's NRC Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics tells Astronomy Now. "People usually study one or the other, not both at the same time. Given the similar masses and dynamic, we believe it is unlikely that both scenarios occur in this system."

Marois continues by explaining that migration of the planets from an initially different location, could provide a solution. "All four planets could have formed at wider separations and then migrated inward, or formed closer-in and then migrated outward. But this complicates the story and it is not obvious that you can move such massive planets over tens of AU and not eject a planet or two in the process, or find stable orbits for all four planets that last tens of millions of years."

Preliminary calculations suggest that the planets c, d and e are in a 1:2:4 orbital resonance, which means for every one orbit that planet c makes, d makes two and e four, much like the situation with Jupiter's moons, Ganymede, Europa and Io.

"Having a resonance is possibly a sign that the planets have moved, but it doesn't tell you by how much they moved," says Marois. "It is possible the planets form at their current location (or close to their current position) and the resonances is part of their formation process. But this problem requires more research and simulations. We are really just at the beginning of this field – we need more planets and more systems like HR 8799 to learn more about how planets form around stars, but it is clear that HR 8799 is already offering a nice challenge. It shows us how little we know about planet formation and how much diversity is out there."

Marois adds that it is possible that smaller rocky planets, currently below the limits of detection, could be located in the inner part of the system. "This would not change the general picture of planet formation, but would make HR 8799 a really close match to our own system – just younger, bigger and with more massive gas giant planets."

The Planets
From tiny Mercury to distant Neptune and Pluto, The Planets profiles each of the Solar System's members in depth, featuring the latest imagery from space missions. The tallest mountains, the deepest canyons, the strongest winds, raging atmospheric storms, terrain studded with craters and vast worlds of ice are just some of the sights you'll see on this 100-page tour of the planets.
 GET YOUR COPY

Hubble Reborn
Hubble Reborn takes the reader on a journey through the Universe with spectacular full-colour pictures of galaxies, nebulae, planets and stars as seen through Hubble's eyes, along the way telling the dramatic story of the space telescope, including interviews with key scientists and astronauts.
 GET YOUR COPY

3D Universe
Witness the most awesome sights of the Universe as they were meant to be seen in this 100-page extravaganza of planets, galaxies and star-scapes, all in 3D!
 GET YOUR COPY


HOME | NEWS ARCHIVE | MAGAZINE | SOLAR SYSTEM | SKY CHART | RESOURCES | STORE | SPACEFLIGHT NOW

© 2014 Pole Star Publications Ltd.